As with last month, I had HONESTLY planned to take a reading break this month. And exactly like last month, reality did not align with my intentions.
Why try to take a reading break when I love reading, you might ask. This Loryn Brantz cartoon sums up my dilemma perfectly! Unlike previous months, all books were fiction.

Without further ado, here is what was on my bookshelf (or, more likely, my Kindle) this past month. I listed the first five in order of my preference. Having Jane Austen rated smack dab in the middle was highly unusual for me.
When reading a book, I almost always think of at least one person I think would enjoy that book. This month, I added this feature.

Title: Remarkably Bright Creatures.
Author: Shelby Van Pelt
Book’s Blurb: A charming, witty and compulsively readable exploration of friendship, reckoning, and hope that traces a widow’s unlikely connection with a Giant Pacific Octopus.
MyRating: *****
Who Might Enjoy this Book: Deb V, octopus lovers and anyone who enjoys feel-good stories told from an animal’s perspective that take life’s tough challenges and make them easier to swallow.
My Review
_________________________

Title: Love Stories
Author: Trent Dalton
Book’s Blurb: Trent Dalton spent two months in 2021 pounding city pavements, speaking to Australians from all walks of life and asking them one simple and direct question: ‘Can you please tell me a love story?’ The result is a warm, wise, poignant, funny and moving book about love in all its guises.
MyRating: ****
Who Might Enjoy this Book: Hopefully, my local book club will enjoy this book. I recommended it to them, and they agreed to read it for their January selection.
My Review
_________________________

Title: Northanger Abbey
Author: Jane Austen
Review from my friend, Jeri: “This novel is more than “just” a satire, however; it’s also an insightful critique of romantic love (at least as portrayed in novels ) while simultaneously containing a full-throated defence of novel reading. Austen’s caustic asides on Catherine’s rather miserable abilities at being a romantic heroine are laugh-out-loud funny.”
MyRating: ****
Who Might Enjoy this Book: My friend, Jeri (quoted above), went through a phase of reading gothic novels in high school, so this hilarious spoof is her favourite Austen novel. If you also enjoy wit, humour and anything gothic (including parodies), this book may be for you.
My Review
_________________________

Title: Cool Waters
Author: Dianne Warren
Book’s Blurb:
This wonderfully entertaining, witty, deeply felt novel brims with forgiveness as its flawed people stumble toward the future.
MyRating: ***½
Who Might Enjoy this Book: Two people I met through blogging immediately came to mind when I read this book. Bernie, who blogs at Equipoise Life and Mona, who currently doesn’t blog but should! This book would be well-suited to fans of Alice Munro and Carol Shields.
My Review

_________________________
Title: Nine Perfect Strangers
Author: Lianne Moriarty
Book’s Blurb: Could ten days at a health resort change you forever? Nine perfect strangers are about to find out.
MyRating: **½
Who Might Enjoy this Book: It is difficult for me to recommend this book as it was not my favourite. My friend Janis said she felt like the author had phoned in the manuscript, and the connection was not good. That at least made me laugh!
My Review: More here
Advanced Reader Copy:

Title: The Wishes of Sisters and Strangers
Author: Antoinette Truglio Martin
Book’s Summary: It is the Christmas and Hanukkah holidays, 1911, in a crowded three-bedroom New York City Apartment. Endless chores, the heaviness of grief, and the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire Trial squash any hope for a peaceful holiday season. The large Sicilian immigrant Taglia family continues to expand, especially with the arrival of a mysterious woman and two boys claiming to be close relatives. With little room or money and constant danger and heartbreak, can the wishes of sisters possibly come true?
MyRating: *****
Order details: Here or Here.
My Review: I was delighted to receive an Advanced Reader Copy of Antoinette Truglio Martin’s The Wishes of Sisters and Strangers (to be published November 7, 2022). I devoured the previous novels in this series, The Heart of Bakers and Artists and Dreams of Singers and Sluggers and was anxious to discover how these stories continued. I absolutely loved how the Taglia story unfolded.
Partly based on the author’s family accounts of coming to America from Sicily in the early 1900s, this series highlights the struggle, barriers and sorrow that so many immigrants endured. Targetted at middle-grade readers, these books can be enjoyed by any age group and would be wonderful shared and discussed. Although I highly recommend reading the entire series, the author has carefully structured The Wishes of Sisters and Strangers so that it also works well as a standalone.
Congratulations to Antoinette Truglio Martin for achieving First Place in the Purple Dragonfly Book Award and receiving The Moonbeam Children’s Book Award. I am confident that more awards are to follow.
I didn’t enjoy Nine Perfect Strangers either and agree it was very formulaic.
LikeLike
Thanks, Barb – I’m glad that it wasn’t just me. I was sad to give Liane Moriarty that low of a rating – especially since I enjoyed the other books of hers that I have read. We will be discussing this book in our upcoming Book Club at the beginning of next month. I will be very interested in hearing what other members thought.
LikeLike
After about 50 pages
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, Ann – That sounds fair. You, Debbie, Sue and Carol will need to teach me how to do this! 😀
LikeLike
As I lie here on the sofa with the ceiling fan on again reading your blog and wondering if I will get up to go get my book to read. Not so far. I enjoy reading your reviews and reading about the political shenanigans in BC and the UK
LikeLike
Hi, Ann – I love the vivid description. I fully agree that some days are meant for lounging (full stop). Thank you for your kind words on my reviews. Usually a short review is more nerve-wracking for me to write than a long blog post! 😀
LikeLike
Too bad about the Liane Moriarty book as Big Little Lies was a wonderful read that i could not put down.
LikeLike
Hi, Luisa – I throughly enjoyed reading Big Little Lies as well as What Alice Forgot. Hopefully Nine Perfect Strangers was simply a one-off!
LikeLike
Oh my gosh. I started with your first book on the list and stopped there and ordered “Remarkably Bright Creatures” for a good friend who is SO into octopus (and he’s a male over the age of 60!). Can’t wait to gift it to him. But I think I’ll want it myself, too!!
LikeLike
Hi, Pam – I’m delighted that you liked this recommendation. If your friend is in octopus, I think that he will love this gift. PS- You may want to (gently) read it first. I think that you will love it too!
LikeLiked by 1 person
xoxo
LikeLiked by 1 person
Such a great post Donna, especially given that you weren’t planning to write one!! I’m so glad you enjoyed Love Stories by Trent Dalton – the premise of it alone was enough for me to know I’d enjoy it. I’m with you on 9 Perfect Strangers, it just didn’t work for me but I’ve heard the Netflix (?) adaptation was quite good and I’ve enjoyed most of her other books too. Also love that you think of who might enjoy a book as you’re reading it – says a lot about you! xx
LikeLike
Hi, Debbie – Thank you for your kind words and ongoing support. I think the Nine Perfect Strangers is (or was) on Hulu. At least that’s what the cover of my book copy told me. Ironically, I believe that Hulu and Brit Box are the only streaming services that Richard doesn’t subscribe too. I am very hesitant to give him any more encouragement in this direction! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Some good recommendations Donna, but I’m not keen on Lianne Moriarty so will give them one a miss. I watched the first episode on Netflix of Nine Perfect Strangers and didn’t enjoy it. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad you managed to get in some reading. Actually, quite a bit of reading. But what is life without reading? I am going to add Martin’s books to my TBR list.
LikeLike
Hi, Laurie – If you and Antoinette are not currently reading each other, you should be. You are two of my two favourite Middle Grades authors (along with Darlene Foster, who you should also be reading)! Oh and I actually read three more books this past month (shhh, don’t tell) but I thought that they would make my post too long so I will include them in next month’s post. Yes, I failed my goal miserably!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
What a great way to fail! 😉 And thank you, thank you, thank you for the very kind words. I will be looking for Antoinette’s and Darlene’s books.
LikeLike
My pleasure! I’ll encourage Antoinette and Darlene to check out your books as well.
LikeLike
Hi Donna – another eclectic mix and interesting that your top pick was a book about a woman and an octopus (who would even think of that as the theme for a novel?!) Loved your brief, pithy reviews and I couldn’t even begin to imagine a month without reading, so I can see why you keep failing on that score 🙂
LikeLike
Yay, I’m not even gonna make that a goal for the month ahead. I am officially waving the white flag! 😀
I hope that all is well with you and that hip is feeling good. Sending big hugs for your speedy recovery!
LikeLike
As soon as I started reading your review of Remarkably Bright Creatures I thought “now, that’s a book I should read”, only to find out you agree! Unfortunately not available on Libby so I’ll source it elsewhere. Thanks, Donna!
Deb
LikeLike
Hi, Deb – Remarkably Bright Creatures is available in hard copy at our library. I promise it will be worth the hard copy read! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pinning several of these books to remember and run by my book club for our next read. Is The Wishes of Sisters and Strangers a children’s book. Let me look it up…ahhh, it is!! Will be checking this out. Do I need to read the other books first? Always glad for a YA or children’s book recommendation.
I have only read one Moriarty book and was not impressed. Found it interesting that you gave Nine Strangers the lowest rating of the books you reviewed. I am not sure what all the hype is for her books.
LikeLike
Hi, Leslie – It is wonderful to hear from you. I hope that all is well for you. Antoinette Martin is a wonderful author for you to check out. I read the series in chronolical order, but you could also read Wishes as a standalone – no problem at all. Nine Perfect Strangers wasn’t for me, but I did enjoy What Alice Forgot and Big Little Lies! 😀
LikeLike
I admit I used to LOVE reading and escaping into fiction when I was much younger. I am pretty sure I am interested more in non-fiction and memoirs as I take on more knowledge about what makes us (me!) humans tick. I listened to Trent narrate his book on the way to listen and see him speak about it earlier this year. We have become friends in a way, and I had to stop and start listening as it was quite an emotional experience. At the Writers Festival he made us all sing “All you need is love”…a fun way to end that session. Thank you for the link up and sharing your thoughts and books. Denyse
LikeLike
Hi, Denyse – It makes sense that we have different reading modes for different times in our lives. When I was a young principal with a young child I don’t think that I ever read one fiction book. I am now making up for lost time. Debbie mentioned that you had a friendship with Trent Dalton. I am totally jealous!
LikeLike
Hi Donna, thanks for sharing your reviews on a diverse range of books. I always love Austen but am now tempted to investigate the Trent Dalton and Remarkably bright creatures books. I was interested that you didn’t really enjoy Liane Moriaty as she seems to be everywhere at the moment.
LikeLike
Hi. Janine – Thank you for stopping by and commenting. In Liane’s defense, I did enjoy two of her earlier books so hopefully Strangers was just a one off. Definitely check out Love Stories and Remarkably Bright Creatures. I think that you will really enjoy them.
LikeLike
Great – I will add them to my immensely long list!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reading fans think alike! I have one of those immensely long TBR piles as well! 😀
LikeLike
I looked for an arc of The Wishes of Sisters and Strangers on Netgalley and couldn’t find it, hopeful it will show up!
LikeLike
Hi, Carol – Wishes od Sisters and Strangers is not on Netgalley but a different share system. I believe that it is still available as an ARC. You can find the link here: https://antoinettetrugliomartin.com/2022/10/16/autumn-coffee-share/ Happy reading!
LikeLike
I’m not familiar with any of these books, but thanks for the reviews. I am always way behind the curve when it comes to reading. I think I go outside too much!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, Ally – In my mind there is no such thing as going outside too much. It always invigorates and heals!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Not bad for wanting to take a reading break, Donna! Lovely reads, the last one would interest my SIL as her family came from Italy. I’m reading three at once, an audiobook collection, Diana Peach’s book Necromancer’s Daughter and a NF, luckily 2 on kindle. I really need to read more. Love your honest reviews!
LikeLike
Hi, Terri – Yes, I failed last month’s non-reading goal miserably! 🙂 If your sister is interested in Antoinette’s book, it still may be available as an ARC. She can find the link here: https://antoinettetrugliomartin.com/2022/10/16/autumn-coffee-share/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, I’ll pass that on!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am the same way with taking a a reading break! LOL. Mostly I ignore all the housework but I do get out for fresh air and then settle in with my reading. I find Moriarty’s book are very hit or miss for me.
LikeLike
Hi, Joanne – I’ve been comforted by the fact that so many readers whom I admire (like you) have found Moriarty’s books to be hit and miss. I’m relieved that it’s not just me!
LikeLike
I really want to read Love Stories – friends keep talking about the stories in it. As for your cartoon, I often read after lunch on a Satruday lying in a beanbag in the sun on the deck,,,so I TOTALLY get that!
LikeLike
Hi, Lydia – I highly recommend Love Stories. Although I usually prefer reading over listening this book was incredible read by the author. Liatening to it on your deck, in the sunhine, would be especially brilliant!
LikeLike
Thanks for the recommendations! More to add to my TBR list.
I can’t help but think that a bestselling author feels under tremendous pressure to follow up with an equally fabulous book, which isn’t always possible. Since I’ve enjoyed her other books, I think I might give Lianne Moriarty a pass for Nine Perfect Strangers. I haven’t read Apples Never Fall, have you?
I just picked up two new books that I had on hold from the library today… fingers crossed!
LikeLike
Hi, Janis – I totally agree that best selling authors likely have incredible stress and pressure in producing their next book. I haven’t read Apples Never Fall but did hear from another blogger today that this book also fell far short of her hopes/expectatons. What books did you recently pick up from the library? I am currently reading Lessons in Chemistry (I am 1/4 of the way through). I will reserve judgement for now! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I read Lessons in Chemistry and liked, not loved, it. I picked up Cloud Cuckoo Land and My Name is Lucy Barton. And, tonight, I attended an author interview of Celeste Ng and received a copy of her new book, Our Missing Hearts. So many books, so little time. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, Janis – You are the third person to mention today about recently attending an in-person author’s talk. I am soooo jealous!
You are the second person to mention today that they did not absolutely love Lessons in Chemistry. I am relieved to hear that. I went into it only seeing/hearing the 5 star reviews. I am currently on page 120 and I am not gonna lie. I have my doubts! I look forward to hearing what you think about the current books you are reading, especially Our Missing Hearts.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the shout out! : ) And I’m SO stealing that cartoon!
LikeLike
My pleasure!
Steal away!
LikeLike
Hi Donna, this is a fabulous post. I loved Love Stories and Northanger Abbey. I should revisit Northanger as it’s years since I read it. I’ve put the Wishes of Sisters and Strangers on my list. It sounds like a book that I’d love. As for taking a reading break, I understand how hard it is to do. I’ve been trying for months as I have three genealogy text books that I need to study. I must try to get them read before the end of the year, so I can get into summer reading.
LikeLike
Thanks, Jennifer. I discovered that I am completely useless at taking a reading break. I honestly did try. I am totally giving up that goal for this month. I am so glad that you enjoyed Love Stories and Northanger Abbey. I am sure that you will enjoy Antoinette Martin’s writing as well. Good luck with your geneology text books!
LikeLike
Hi Donna, A reading break for you sounds like ‘mission impossible’ 🙂 Thank you for sharing your book reviews. I just started Scarborough by Catherine Hernandez, a new-to-me Canadian author. Her book was shortlisted for several awards and adapted to screen as a feature film and premiered at Toronto International Film Festival last year. I look forward to reading it to the end.
LikeLike
Hi, Natalie – Thank you for letting me know about Catherine Hernandez. I sadly don’t know about her or her writing. I am off to look her up now!
LikeLike
Some from me – https://travelswithali.com/2022/10/22/%f0%9f%93%9a-whats-on-your-bookshelf-october-2022-%f0%9f%93%9a/
LikeLike
Hi, Alison – Thank you for joining us. I just popped over to your post and loved it. You gave a wonderful reminder of different books for different folks. No right or wrong. This is great to remember as we read. Now I just need to give myself permission to not finish a book once I have started. I am always sure that it will get better — even when I have solid evidence to the contrary! 😦
LikeLike
And even if the reviews are good
Sometimes you just don’t comment ĺ
LikeLike
Posted before I finished! Meant to say connect!
LikeLike
So true, Alison. And ‘comment’ works as well.
LikeLike
Hi Donna – as usual I’ve read lots of pieces of various books – nothing as a novel. A friend recommended ‘What the Water Gave Me’ ) Poems after Frida Kahlo – by Pascale Petit (a visual artist/ now poet) … it was shortlisted for the 2010 TS Eliot prize. My honorary god-daughter loves Frida Kahlo’s work … so I thought it’d be a good birthday present …
… then she and her new fiance love Italy … so I’ve go a copy of ‘The Epic History of Italians and their Food’ … very interesting. But I’m drafting up a talk on the Foundling Hospital in London for our Georgian History group … life goes on – let alone the politics?! Always lovely to see your posts … cheers Hilary
LikeLike
Hi, Hilary – You frequently inspire me to look up new-to-me books and authors. I am now off to look up Frida Kahlo as well as The Epic History of Italians and their food. Best of luck with your talk!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry forgot to put in the title of the Italian book ‘Delizia!’ or the author … he is English and lives in London … John Dickie – glad I send you off to look things up – inspires me .. thank you! Cheers Hilary
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awesome! Thank you!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Donna I felt disappointed when I read Nine Perfect Strangers. It definitely wasn’t up to the usual standard of her previous books. I love how you have added ‘who might enjoy this book’to your reviews. I’m keen to read all of your recommendations. Xx
LikeLike
Hi, Sue – You truly are a Rock Star! Not only did you post while you are traveling — you commented on other posts as well! Very impressive! I hope that your travels are going well. Your photos are fabulous!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m intrigued by Remarkably Bright Creatures, which I’d never heard of. What an unusual premise for a book! I might have to read it out of sheer curiosity.
LikeLike
Hi, Janet – Remarkably Bright Creatures is quirky, fun and a quick read. You do have to suspend belief about Marcelius right from the start. Once you do, the book is quite the ride. Hope you enjoy it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
First, thank you, thank you for the wonderful review of The Wishes of Sisters and Strangers. I am so pleased you 5 star liked it!
I agree with 9 Strangers, I couldn’t cheer for any chara ter and the twist was obvious from the beginning. Have you see the Netflix documentary, My Octopus Teacher. It sounds like the remarkable creatures would be a good companion.
As always, so impressed with your reads. Thank you for the recommendations.
LikeLike
Hi, Antoinette -My only dislike about The Wishes of Sisters and Strangers was that it is the last in the series – with no more to follow. 😦
I am surprised to find that so many of my friends also did not love Nine Perfect Strangers. Just goes to show – you never know until you ask,,,or until you share! I couldn’t find the movie version on Netflix. In Canada, I believe it is on Hulu (one of two streaming services that my husband actually does not subscribe to).
I loved, loved, loved My Octopus Teacher. It does make a great companion to Remarkably Bright Creatures!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I haven’t read the Trent Dalton as I don’t like non-fiction but like his writing in general. And I completely agree re Nine Perfect Strangers. I HATED it. I’m actually not that much of a Lianne Moriarty fan I must admit as I didn’t like Big Little Lies that much either. (Certainly not like others seemed to!)
LikeLike
Hi, Deb – Thank you so much for commenting. I very much respect your opinion on books. I have other friends who don’t like non-fiction, so I totally get that. I am currently reading Lessons In Chemistry. Have you read that? I am half way through and it is seeming like a totally different book than what I expected.
LikeLike
Donna,
I suppose I prefer to be outside. Where you failed at taking a break, I failed in reading more than I intended (one novel). Nevertheless, I loved reading your reviews and the comments from you and your readers about the books you chose.
I look forward to next month’s list. You HAVE to be a speed reader. Have a great week. Joe
LikeLike
That last sentence was worded awkwardly. I should have asked, “are you a speed reader?”
LikeLike
Hi, Joe – I didn’t think your last sentence was awkwardly stated. I took it as a conpliment!
LikeLike
Hi, Joe – I’m definitely not a speed reader. I simply spend lots of time reading. I don’t watch television and I watch very few movies, so some time comes from there. I also don’t work, so tons of time comes from there. Last week, I walked 55 kms so I do actively get outdoors but never as much as I would like. Thank you for your kind words on my reviews. For me, that’s always the hard part!
LikeLiked by 1 person
What an eclectic booklist! And so many inciteful comments. I haven’t read any of the books on your list and realize I really should broaden my reading beyond Westerns and non-fic!
Subscribing!
LikeLike
Hi, Jacqui – Great minds think alike! Last night, I opened your website with the purpose of following your blog, but I see my request did not go through. I tried again now and I’m subscribed. I’m looking forward to following.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love talking books so always notice bloggers with interesting articles. I surely think you qualify!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, Jacqui – I absolutely love discussing books. I just came back from one of my bookclubs (I currently belong to three). Discussing books is such a great way to connect with others and to reveal core values!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Three book clubs! I’m impressed. What fun.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Jacqui – During the height of Pandemic Lockdown I was in five different bookclubs. Hopeless, I know! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks as always for the book reviews, Donna. I appreciate the added feature of who might enjoy the book. I am a fan of Lianne Moriarty, but did not read Nine Perfect Strangers. Perhaps I won’t bother. I recently read her Apples Never Fall and loved it.
LikeLike
Hi, Christie- Thank you for reading and commenting. I believe that authors that write and publish as much as Lianne does are allowed a miss or two here or there. The pressure on them, especially following an immensely popular best seller, must be incredibly stressful!
LikeLike
Thanks, for the book reviews, Donna!
LikeLike